AI image generators compared.
We gave 16 image models in Nutcracker the same ten briefs for one beer: a packshot, a poster, a billboard, a chalkboard menu, a stadium crowd. One take each, nothing picked or retouched. Where Arena’s public blind-vote leaderboard rates a model, its takes carry that Elo, so you can hold the ranking up to the pictures.
Run 7 November 2026 · 143 pictures · 388 credits in all
Image 1.
Eight of the ten briefs send this photo of the can and ask for its label exactly as it is: STRAIGHT FACE at the top, a large 0.0 with a flat white line under it, LAGER · 0.0% ALCOHOL · 12 FL OZ at the bottom.
Straight Face is a sample brand made with Nutcracker.

01 Packshot.
1:1 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for every word of the label, the flat line, condensation.
«Studio packshot for an online shop. Image 1 is the product: keep its label exactly as it is, with STRAIGHT FACE at the top, the large 0.0 with a flat white line under it, and LAGER · 0.0% ALCOHOL · 12 FL OZ at the bottom. The can stands upright, turned slightly left, on a pale grey seamless sweep, with cold condensation on its lower half. One large softbox from the upper left, neutral white balance, a soft shadow falling right. Photorealistic, natural saturation, soft contrast. No other text.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 2 min 42 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 55 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 2 min 21 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 5 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 19 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 35 s

FLUX 3
2 credits · 59 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 2 min 32 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 1 min 15 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 25 s

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 53 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 26 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 22 s

Krea 3
5 credits · 33 s
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
02 In hand.
2:3 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for hands, the label on a curve at an angle, a phone-photo look.
«A phone photo for an Instagram post. A woman's hand holds the can from Image 1 out toward the camera at a backyard barbecue in late afternoon, the label facing us and reading exactly as in Image 1. Behind her, out of focus, friends stand around a smoking grill. Low warm sun from behind, about 4500K. Honest and unposed, real skin texture, everyday detail. Natural saturation. No other text.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 42 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 38 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 28 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 14 s
Turned her hand into a woman in a bikini top.

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 31 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 47 s

FLUX 3
2 credits · 34 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 2 min 31 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 1 min 40 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 25 s

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 45 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 26 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 22 s

Krea 3
5 credits · 28 s
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
03 Campaign poster.
2:3 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for a headline set right, an idea in one frame, faces in a room.
«A print poster for a beer campaign. At a wedding reception every guest is crying with laughter at a speech, except one man in a grey suit who holds the can from Image 1 and looks straight into the camera with a completely flat face. On-camera flash, the room falling into warm darkness behind. Across the top in large white bold condensed sans-serif capitals: KEEP A STRAIGHT FACE. The headline appears once. No other text apart from the can's label.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 34 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 23 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 29 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 22 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 32 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 39 s
Added a full stop to the headline.

FLUX 3
2 credits · 48 s
Added a full stop to the headline.

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 2 min 40 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 1 min 23 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 29 s

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 49 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 27 s
Added a full stop to the headline.

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 25 s

Krea 3
5 credits · 30 s
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
04 Billboard in place.
16:9 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for perspective, words on a surface in a real street, mixed light.
«A photo of a billboard for a client presentation. A large billboard on a brick wall above a corner bar at dusk. On it, on a flat black background: the can from Image 1, very large on the right, and on the left in white bold sans-serif: "Good question." Two lamps light the billboard from its top edge; the street below is wet, and a man walks past with his collar up. Cool 6500K dusk sky, warm sodium street light. Photorealistic, natural saturation. No other text apart from the can's label.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 2 min 46 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 21 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 1 min 26 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 22 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 22 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 40 s

FLUX 3
2 credits · 34 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 4 min 14 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 2 min 26 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 30 s

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 40 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 27 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 23 s

Krea 3
5 credits · 28 s
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
05 Flat illustration.
1:1 · words only, no photo
Look for a graphic register, three colours, holding back.
«A flat vector illustration for a social post. A bar counter seen side-on: five beer glasses overflowing with big cartoon foam, and among them one matte black can standing perfectly still, with a large white 0.0 on it and a short flat white line under it like a straight mouth. Three colours only: black, off-white and a warm yellow for the beer. Bold flat shapes, no outlines, no gradients, plenty of empty space above. No text except the 0.0 on the can.»

Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 1 min 2 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 1 min 4 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 44 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 19 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 13 s · see-through background
Four glasses, not five.

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 29 s · see-through background

FLUX 3
2 credits · 22 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 1 min 40 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 51 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 20 s

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 44 s
Shaded glasses and a dark stout: more than three flat colours.

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 29 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 20 s

Krea 3
3 credits · 15 s

Recraft V4.1 Pro
Arena 1132 · 10 credits · 18 s
Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG
12 credits · 20 s
06 Chalkboard menu.
9:16 · words only, no photo
Look for many small words spelled right, hand lettering.
«A photo of a chalkboard drinks menu on a bar wall, for an Instagram story. Hand-lettered in white and yellow chalk, line by line: DRAUGHT, then "Pale Ale $6", "Stout $7", "Lager $6", a gap, then "Straight Face 0.0 $5", with a small chalk smiley whose mouth is a flat line. Each line appears once. Warm tungsten bar light from the left, a little chalk dust. Photorealistic. No other text.»

Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 1 min 29 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 17 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 50 s
Put the price mid-name: Straight $5, Face 0.0.

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 17 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 15 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 26 s

FLUX 3
2 credits · 24 s
The smiley smiles. The brief asked for a flat mouth.

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 1 min 18 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 46 s
The smiley smiles. The brief asked for a flat mouth.

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 20 s
The smiley smiles. The brief asked for a flat mouth.

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 35 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 33 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 28 s

Krea 3
3 credits · 16 s
The smiley smiles. The brief asked for a flat mouth.

Recraft V4.1 Pro
Arena 1132 · 10 credits · 24 s
Came back at 8:13, not the 9:16 asked for.
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
07 Six-pack.
3:2 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for the can's design carried onto a new pack, six cans that match.
«A product photo for a packaging presentation. A cardboard six-pack carrier holding six cans from Image 1, on a white table. The carrier is matte black like the can, with the same large white 0.0 and flat white line on its side, and STRAIGHT FACE in white capitals above it, in the can's typeface. Soft window light from the left, neutral white balance, a gentle shadow. Natural saturation, soft contrast. No other text apart from the cans' labels.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 44 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 23 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 31 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 12 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 25 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 33 s

FLUX 3
2 credits · 39 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 3 min 7 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 1 min 56 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 29 s

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 44 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 27 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 19 s

Krea 3
5 credits · 28 s
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
08 The pour.
16:9 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for liquid, foam, bubbles, backlight.
«A close photo for a website banner. Lager poured from the can from Image 1 into a tall glass: pale gold and clear, a thick white head rising, small bubbles streaming up. The can tilts in from the top right, its label readable. Dark slate background, one hard light from behind so the beer glows, neutral white balance. Photorealistic, natural saturation, soft contrast. No other text apart from the can's label.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 2 min 58 s
The pour misses the glass.

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 19 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 1 min 28 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 1 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 19 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 39 s

FLUX 3
2 credits · 29 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 2 min 45 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 1 min 33 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 28 s

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 37 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 30 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 2 min 24 s

Krea 3
5 credits · 26 s
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
09 The can as a character.
1:1 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for a 3D render that keeps the product's design.
«A 3D render for a sticker pack. The can from Image 1 as a cartoon character with short arms and legs, sitting on a bar stool with its arms crossed. The 0.0 reads as its eyes and the flat white line as its mouth, unchanged from Image 1. Clean toy-like render, smooth satin finish, soft global illumination, a plain pale yellow background. Saturated colour, gentle contrast. No text apart from the can's label.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 2 min 44 s

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 21 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 1 min 47 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 24 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 24 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 37 s · see-through background
Left out the pale yellow background the brief asked for.

FLUX 3
2 credits · 1 min 6 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 3 min 3 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 1 min 22 s
Printed the 0.0 twice.

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 29 s
Moved the dot off the 0.0.

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 51 s
Put cartoon eyes over the 0.0.

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 27 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 22 s
Dropped the dot and drew a second mouth.

Krea 3
5 credits · 27 s
Printed the 0.0 twice.
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
10 The stand.
9:16 · with the can photo as Image 1
Look for a crowd of faces and hands, motion, one still man.
«A vertical photo for a TikTok cover. A packed stadium stand right after a goal: every fan is mid-scream with arms up. In the middle, one man in a green scarf sits calmly holding the can from Image 1, his face completely flat. Shot from a few rows below, grey daylight, motion blur on the cheering arms. Honest and unposed, real skin texture. Natural saturation. No text apart from the can's label.»


Nano Banana 2.1
Arena 1325 · 2 credits · 3 min

Nano Banana 2
2 credits · 25 s

Nano Banana Pro
Arena 1232 · 4 credits · 41 s

GPT Image 2
Arena 1382 · 2 credits · 1 min 10 s

GPT Image 2.6 Flare
Arena 1383 · 2 credits · 26 s

GPT Image 2.6 Sunburst
Arena 1409 · 2 credits · 32 s

FLUX 3
2 credits · 29 s

Riverflow 2.6 Pro
7 credits · 2 min 47 s

Seedream 5 Pro
Arena 1250 · 2 credits · 1 min 34 s

Seedream 5 Flash
1 credit · 28 s
The calm fan has no face.

Qwen Image 2.1 Pro
2 credits · 40 s

MAI-Image-2.6
Arena 1330 · 2 credits · 30 s

Grok Imagine 2.0
Arena 1289 · 1 credit · 22 s

Krea 3
5 credits · 30 s
Sat out: Recraft V4.1 Pro (takes no reference image), Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG (a vector model, run on the flat illustration only).
Price and wait.
What one picture cost and how long it took. Open a model to see every picture it made.
| Model | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1325 | 2 | 2 min 6 s | |
| – | 2 | 23 s | |
| 1232 | 4 | 47 s | |
| OpenAI | 1382 | 2 | 1 min 16 s |
| OpenAI | 1383 | 2 | 23 s |
| OpenAI | 1409 | 2 | 36 s |
| Black Forest Labs | – | 2 | 34 s |
| Sourceful | – | 7 | 2 min 43 s |
| ByteDance | 1250 | 2 | 1 min 28 s |
| ByteDance | – | 1 | 28 s |
| Alibaba | – | 2 | 44 s |
| Microsoft | 1330 | 2 | 27 s |
| xAI | 1289 | 1 | 22 s |
| Krea | – | 3–5 | 28 s |
| Recraft | 1132 | 10 | 21 s |
| Recraft | – | 12 | 20 s |
Arena Elo is the score on Arena’s text-to-image leaderboard on 6 November 2026, from blind votes on general prompts, rounded (CC BY 4.0). Arena may run a model at other quality settings than ours, and the newest models’ scores rest on fewer votes. Arena doesn’t rate Nano Banana 2, FLUX 3, Riverflow 2.6 Pro, Seedream 5 Flash, Qwen Image 2.1 Pro, Krea 3, and Recraft V4.1 Pro SVG as we run them.
Credits are our own quote for each picture on 7 November 2026, at the model’s default size; 1,000 credits are $50 of top‑ups. A wait runs from the click to the finished picture on that day, so the provider’s queue counts; typical is the middle of the model’s takes. Our Terms let you use what you make commercially, whatever the model. Makers’ own terms: model licenses.
How we ran it.
- 1
The same words and the same can photo went to every model. No model got wording of its own.
- 2
Each model ran at its default size in Nutcracker, in the shape the brief asked for.
- 3
One take each, nothing picked or retouched. No provider failed, so nothing was run twice.
- 4
A note marks a miss you can see at this size. Open a picture to check the label up close.
Run on 7 November 2026 in Nutcracker’s Craft. On the sheets, pictures are scaled to 960 pixels on the long side; opened, they show at the size the model made them, up to 1600. The vector model’s SVG is served as it came.
Or just ask.
Here every model got the same prompt, so the test is fair. In Nutcracker you don’t have to write one: it comes up with the idea and writes the prompt itself. You can still write your own in Craft. We sent it one line and the can photo.
«Make a campaign poster for Straight Face. This is our can.»
It read the brand’s platform, looked at the can and came back in under a minute with two poster ideas, each with its own line, then drew both on Nano Banana 2.1, our default; name another model and it switches.

Good question · its pick
The can’s face painted huge on a bar wall, the can standing under it. The question on top changes from poster to poster; the answer never does.
Nano Banana 2.1 · 2 credits · 4 min 7 s from the ask
Added a third zero at the wall’s right edge.
The prompt it wrote
«A 3:4 campaign poster, a documentary photograph of a dim empty bar at night. The back wall is matte black. On it, painted in flat white, is a gigantic face made of two tall rounded zeros with a round dot between them and one flat horizontal line below as a mouth. The face is so large it runs off the left, right and top edges of the frame. A plain dark wooden bar top crosses the lower third. Centred on the bar top, directly under the wall's flat mouth, stands one matte black 12 oz beer can, shown exactly as in Image 1: a giant white 0.0 and one flat white line under it, 'STRAIGHT FACE' above in small white condensed capitals, 'LAGER · 0.0% ALCOHOL · 12 FL OZ' small at the bottom, silver top. Keep the can's artwork exactly as Image 1. One soft warm pendant light from above left lands on the can and leaves the wall mostly dark. Small grey condensed sans text at the top centre: 'Why a zero?' White condensed sans text centred under the can, medium size: 'Good question.' No people, no glasses.»

Second question
Every flat-faced drinker at the table turns to the raised can: “What’s that you’re having?” The room changes from poster to poster.
Nano Banana 2.1 · 2 credits · 4 min 45 s from the ask
Showed four faces whole; the prompt asked for mouths only.
The method behind the ideas: key visual.
Try them on your brand.
Ask in your own words, with your own product photo. 7 days free, no card.
Already in? Sign in